One of the most common questions Healthwick’s customer service team encounters is whether plastic-backed or cloth-backed adult diapers are the better choice.
The truth is, both offer unique benefits depending on your needs, lifestyle, and personal preference. From breathability and comfort to leak protection and durability, each option serves a different purpose.
Read on to learn the key differences and which option is best suited for you!
Quick History
-
1800s: The earliest forms of adult incontinence protection date back to individuals using folded linen or other fabric materials, often secured with safety pins.
-
1940s: Major innovations in adult diaper construction began, with materials such as rubber and nylon introduced to improve outer containment and leak resistance.
-
1970s: As awareness of incontinence needs grew within medical settings, the first plastic-backed disposable adult diapers started to appear more widely.
-
1990s: The introduction of super-absorbent polymers (SAP) — highly effective liquid-absorbing materials — led to major improvements in absorbency and the development of more discreet products such as pull-up underwear and pads.
-
2000s–Present: Driven by an aging population and increased awareness, innovation in incontinence products has rapidly expanded, with wider product ranges, improved materials, and more comfortable, discreet designs.
Cloth-Backed Adult Diapers
-
Breathability: Cloth-backed adult diapers are often preferred for their soft feel and improved airflow, which can help reduce heat buildup and keep skin feeling cooler and drier throughout the day. This makes them a popular choice for those with sensitive skin or for extended wear during warmer months.
-
Leak Protection and Odour Control: Modern cloth-backed designs still offer excellent absorbency and reliable protection, making them well suited for moderate levels of incontinence. For those who need added capacity, supplemental products such as booster pads can be used to increase absorption without sacrificing comfort.
-
Discretion and Everyday Comfort: Cloth-backed diapers, especially pull-up style adult underwear, provide a quieter and more flexible wearing experience. Their softer outer material helps reduce crinkling sounds and stay more discreet under clothing.
Healthwick's Cloth-Backed Favourites
Plastic-Backed Adult Diapers
-
Breathability: Plastic-backed diapers use a moisture-resistant outer layer to lock in wetness and help keep it away from the skin. While they may feel slightly warmer than cloth-backed options, many users still find them highly effective for maintaining dryness.
-
Leak Protection and Odour Control: Thanks to their waterproof outer layer, plastic-backed diapers offer superior leak resistance during movement and while sleeping. This design also helps trap odours more effectively, making them an excellent choice for higher absorbency needs and extended wear.
-
Discretion and Everyday Comfort: Plastic-backed diapers can sometimes produce faint crinkling sounds due to their firmer materials and structured design. However, this added structure provides extra security and containment, which is why many people prefer them for overnight use.
Healthwick's Plastic-Backed Favourites
"So which option is better?"
While there’s no clear-cut answer, each option is designed to meet different comfort and protection needs:
Cloth-backed adult diapers are best for those who prioritize breathability, softness, and discretion for everyday wear or moderate incontinence needs.
Plastic-backed diapers are ideal for heavier incontinence, overnight use, and anyone who wants maximum leak protection and moisture containment.
No matter your needs, exploring both styles can help you discover the protection and comfort that works best for you.
Next Steps
If you're still unsure which products are right for you, use our free sample program to see which products fit your lifestyle, or contact our friendly customer service team for personalized support.
Take Care!
Canada's Largest Selection - Free Samples - Same Day Shipping, Order by Noon*
Visit USA shop
